Granduncle Mark's Genealogy Parlor


Simon Elias Routh
1871-1933

Reported by Simon's great-grandson,
Mark Ellsworth Hickman, PhD

Click here to contact me


    Photo at left is Simon Elias Routh
    in the Philippine Islands
    during the Spanish American War.

    --- Click on photo to see larger photo!







    My great-grandparents at right:

    Simon Elias Routh and Nannie (Martin) Routh.

    Simon was born 12 Dec 1871 in Tippecanoe County, Indiana. He was the son of Benjamin Hopkins Routh and Barbara Ann (Summers) Routh.

    Nannie was born 22 Jan 1877 in Blair County, Pennsylvania. She was the daughter of James Frederick Martin and Eliza Jane (Lowmiller, Plank) Martin.

    --- Click on photo to see larger photo!









    Photo on left shows my great-grandfather, Simon Elias Routh, with his mother, Barbara Ann (Summers) Routh (on the left), and his sister, Elizabeth Alice (Routh) Dobson (on the right, in the white dress). The name of the horse is not known.


    --- Click on photo to see larger photo!















    On the right is a photograph of my great-grandfather, Simon Elias Routh.

    Simon was the father of Velva Deliliah "Jean" (Routh) Houghton, Elda Elizabeth (Routh) Eddleman, and Lawrence "Joe" Routh.







    Simon Elias Routh was born 12 December 1871 in Tippecanoe County, Indiana. He was the fourth child of Benjamin Hopkins Routh and Barbara Ann (Summers) Routh.


    Simon's paternal grandparents were Jacob Routh (1821-1846) and Elizabeth (Hopkins) Routh (born 1824).

    Simon's maternal grandparents were John and Elizabeth Summers (both born in 1812).


    Simon was the great-grandson of Issac Routh (born 1775) and Sarah (Sloat) Routh (born 1781), who married in Jefferson County, Tennessee; and of Benjamin Hopkins and Mary C. (Skeen) Hopkins (born in 1787).


    Simon was the great-great-grandson of Jacob Routh (1745-1827) and Martha (Redfern) Routh (1747-1837).


    Simon's great-great-great-grandfather was either Zacheus Routh (born 03 December 1717) or Edward Routh (born 25 March 1713).


    Simon's great-great-great-great-grandparents were Lawrence Routh (born 1687) and Mehitable (_______) Routh.


    Simon's great-great-great-great-great-grandparents were Lawrence Routh (born 1660) and Ann (Metcalfe) Routh (born 1665).


    Simon had three older brothers, John Daniel Routh, Jesse Michael Routh, and David Ira Routh. Simon's two younger brothers were Francis Leroy Routh and Orval Clifton Routh. Simon's two younger sisters were Elizabeth Alice Routh and Nora Estella Routh.


    The Routh home in which Simon was reared was a prosperous farm family in Tippecanoe County, Indiana.

    Simon experienced the death of siblings when he was 10-years old. Simon's sister, Nora, died at the age of 13-months that year. The following month, Simon's 3-year old brother, Francis, also died. Simon's oldest brother died at the age of 18-years, when Simon was only 11 years old. This must have been a very difficult period for the Routh's as the family lost three children within a 6-month period between September 1881 and March 1882.

    Simon's father, Benjamin, died when Simon was 27-years of age. Simon's mother remarried a few years later to George Grubb. When Simon was 37-years old his youngest brother, Orval, died at the age of 26-years. When Simon was 55-years old, his brother Jesse died in an unusual accident, falling off of a railroad car. Elda recalls that her usually-stern father cried upon learning of the death of his mother, Barbara Ann (Summers) Routh. Clearly, the pain of death was a frequent visitor in Simon's life.

    Simon's sister, Elizabeth Alice, know as 'Aunt Alice,' was reported by many family members to have possessed powers of levitation and spirit writing. It is also said that she stopped using these powers later in her life for religious reasons.

    At the age of 27-years, Simon enlisted in the Army on 19 September 1899. He was in Company I of the 38th Regiment of Infantry during the Spanish-American War. His honorable discharge on 30 June 1901 described him as 5'-11" tall with dark complexion, brown eyes and black hair.

    The war took Simon across the Pacific Ocean. During the Spanish American War, Simon fought in at least ten significant battles in the Philippine Islands. He was not physically wounded in these battles, but he did contract Malaria during his service. He received a government pension for his military service.

    After the war, Simon remain single for a few more years. Coming from an affluent family and having been a very independent bachelor for several years, Simon was accustomed to selecting his activities and pursuing his own fancies. He did not have financial or familial demands to distract him from pursuing his own interests.

    Simon was meticulous about his physical appearance. Throughout his life he would only wear Stetson hats and he shined his shoes so thoroughly that he could see his reflection in them. This history of privilege, combined with his overseas combat experience and multiple deaths of close family members during his childhood, surely affected his outlook on life.

    Simon was usually an emotionally reserved man who isolated himself in his room to write articles for publication. Nevertheless, he was also a man of strong temperament whose adjustment to family life was complicated by his stern approach. A strict father, he did not expect defiance or unfinished chores.

    More positively, Simon is also remembered as a brilliant and creative man. He was a talented writer. For many years his political commentaries were regularly published by the National Tribune. In the evenings he sat for hours at his roll-top desk, fully absorbed in his political writings. A public stenographer typed his handwritten articles.

    Simon's writings reflected his strong allegiance to the Democratic Party, and it was an ongoing source of frustration for Simon that his wife, Nannie (Martin) Routh, defined herself as a Republican.

    Simon invented many labor-saving devices for his farm after he moved his family to Stanford, Indiana, such as a device which automatically dispensed hog feed in measured amounts. He made with his own hands beautiful furniture for his home. He was a skilled farmer and on an 8-acre farm he maintained a thousand chickens, hogs, a Jersey cow named 'ol' Rhone, orchards (pears, peaches, cherries and apples), strawberries and vegetable gardens.

    Simon Elias Routh met his future wife in a novel way. In those days, it was acceptable for a young woman to indicate her willingness to meet a suitor by writing her name and address on an egg before the egg was shipped to market. A young woman named, Jesse Martin, wrote on an egg at her Blair County, Pennsylvania farm. The egg ended up in the possession of Simon Routh. Simon began a correspondence with Jesse and eventually travelled to Blair County, Pennsylvania, with the idea that he would marry her. When Simon visited at the Martin home, however, Simon and Jesse found that they were not compatible. Instead, Simon was attracted to Jesse's younger sister, Nannie Martin. He pursued Nannie's interest, promising her a year-long honeymoon if she would marry him.

    Although Nannie Martin had previously cared for another man in her native Pennsylvania, she did ultimately accept Simon's proposal. On 11 March 1907 in Hollidaysburg, Blair County, Pennsylvania, Simon Elias Routh married Nannie Martin, the daughter of James Frederick Martin and Eliza Jane (Lowmiller, Plank) Martin. They were married by Pastor W. F. Schwartz.

    Nannie was 29-years of age when she married the 35-year old Simon. It was the only marriage for each of them. As each of them had experienced part of their adult lives as single people, they were both fiercely independent and inclined to state their positions directly. Nannie described herself as being "as independent as a hog on ice." There were, needless to say, some bumpy rides ahead for the strong-willed couple, neither fearing to speak their mind to the other.

    Simon and Nannie embarked on a year-long honeymoon, as Simon had promised. During this time, they toured the continental United States. Nannie, however, became pregnant immediately after the marriage and wanted to establish a home. Simon, however, was an affluent man who didn't have a financial imperative to work, and as a bachelor for several years, he did not have experience with putting down the kind of roots that Nannie desired for their family. During that first year, Simon sometimes took brief jobs, such as doing landscaping work on Texas ranches, but Nannie sometimes found him sleeping behind the very hedges he was supposed to trim.

    Simon and Nannie's first child, Velva Delilah Routh, was born nine months after the marriage, on 17 December 1907 in Springfield, Greene County, Missouri, which is near the Ozark Mountains in southwestern Missouri.

    Further information about Simon and Nannie's children is presented below.

    There were difficult moments for Simon. On the occasion of one of his birthdays, a cold December morning, he fell through the boards of the outhouse, being fully immersed in the icy waste water. His daughter, Elda, recalls that when Simon yelled for help, both she and her sister refused to help him 'because he smelled so awful' after his plunge. Simon had to burn his clothing and spend the rest of that birthday building a new floor in the outhouse.

    Simon Elias Routh was ill during the last ten years of his life. His daughter, Elda, moved in with her family to care for him. Simon suffered from diabetes, dropsy, mitral insufficiency and chronic myocarditis. The last two of these conditions were the cause of his death at 61-years of age on Tuesday morning, 25 April 1933 in Monroe County, Indiana. His body was initially taken for preparation to the Weir Funeral Home in Bloomington, Indiana, but then returned to his home where he laid in state until funeral services at his home. Simon was buried at the Greene County Chapel Cemetery, just across the county line from his Stanford, Indiana home community. At the time of his burial, a volley of shots was fired by a firing squad over his grave to commemorate his status as a veteran of the Spanish American War.







    Simon Elias Routh's wife, Nannie (Martin) Routh had three children and four pregnancies:

  • Velva Delilah "Jean" Routh was born nine months after Simon and Nannie's marriage. Velva was born 17 December 1907 in Springfield, Greene County, Missouri, which is near the Ozark Mountains in southwestern Missouri. Velva was named in honor of a close childhood friend of Nannie. Simon selected 'Delilah' as Velva's middle name. However, Velva did not like either of her given names, so elected to call herself, 'Jean,' a name that she retained throughout life. This self-selected name was so accepted that when Velva's niece was named in her honor, the name given was 'Winifred Jean.' Jean married Warren HOUGHTON.

  • Elda Elizabeth Routh was born 26 August 1910 in Danville, Vermillion County, Illinois. Elda's name was given in honor of Nannie's childhood friend, Elda Houck. Elda's middle name, 'Elizabeth,' was a tribute to Nannie's sister, although Simon also had a sister named, Elizabeth Alice (Routh) Dobson. Simon's nickname for Elda was 'Tom,' and he later named one of his twin mules 'Tom,' saying the mule had been named for Elda. The Martin family called Elda, 'Betty.' Elda was married on 11 July 1929 in Monroe County, Indiana to Clarence Noble EDDLEMAN.

  • Lawrence Routh, Nannie's third child, was born 14 March 1913 in Danville, Vermillion County, Illinois. Lawrence had no official middle name, but has gone by, Lawrence J. Routh, because his father always called him 'Joe,' as a nickname. Lawrence was born 7 days after his parent's 6th wedding anniversary, when Simon was 41-years old and Nannie was 36-years of age. 'Lawrence' is a name that has occurred frequently in the Routh family over many generations.

  • Nannie's fourth pregnancy was miscarried late in that pregnancy. This baby was a boy, so he would have been Simon and Nanny's second son. Nannie was in her late 30's, and Simon in his mid-40's, when this baby was lost. The loss of this baby occurred when the family was moving from Danville, Illinois to Frankfort, Indiana, but somehow Nannie ended up hospitalized in Dayton, Ohio. Nannie's doting Uncle, William Cutler, who lived in Ohio, found out about her hospitalization and visited her every day that she was in the hospital.






  • Simon Elias Routh had five grandchildren:


    • Winifred Jean (EDDLEMAN) HICKMAN (Born 29 July 1930 in Stanford, Monroe County, Indiana. Married 24 April 1948 in Johnson County, Indiana to Harold Ellsworth Hickman. Winifred died 24 August 1996 at her home in Bloomington, Monroe County, Indiana.)

    • Donald Welbourne HOUGHTON (Born 26 September 1930 in Detroit, Michigan. Married to Grace Lorraine Wilson. Died: 30 December 1994 in Las Vegas, Nevada. Retired USN as LCDR, worked at Flamingo Hilton Hotel as an auditor until around 1992.

    • Janice Sue (EDDLEMAN) WELLMAN (Born 17 September 1932 in Monroe County, Indiana. Married 15 August 1953 in Clear Creek, Monroe County, Indiana to Samuel Eugene Wellman.)

    • Elizabeth Ann (EDDLEMAN) HAZEL (Born 16 February 1935 in Monroe County, Indiana. Married 24 April 1954 in Clear Creek, Monroe County, Indiana to Carl Morris Hazel.)

    • Allan W. HOUGHTON









    Simon Elias Routh has sixteen great-grandchildren:








      Simon Elias Routh has over 30 great-great-grandchildren, with several of these already being adults themselves.








    See Also:









    Copyright 1996-2006, Granduncle Mark
    (Mark Ellsworth Hickman, PhD)




    Granduncle Mark's Genealogy Parlor

    Click here to contact me